Can House Prices Rise as Sales Slow?

Here is an interesting picture. The S&P/Case-Shiller House Price index showed prices in the 20 largest cities increased 13.3 percent annually in September, the highest year-over-year increase since February 2006. Yet, existing home sales have slowed a bit and pending home sales have been lower for several months, according to the National Association of Realtors. How can home prices be rising at a time in which home sales are slowing down? The answer is found in two important numbers. For one, the percentage of distressed sales is falling as the foreclosure inventory shrinks. LPS reports that the foreclosure inventory is down 30% over the past year. Since distressed homes sell at a significant discount over non-distressed sales, it makes sense that the average sale price is rising. During the height of the housing crisis, the flood of foreclosed homes exaggerated the drop in home prices and on the way out of the crisis, the rise in home prices his now exaggerated by the lower numbers of these sales.

Secondly, we still have a lack of inventory in many markets, especially at the lower end of the market. Housing sales are being held back because of this lack of inventory but at the same time we are not seeing slower housing sales cause downward pressure on prices. If there is more demand than supply, prices will be stable or rise regardless of the number of total sales. What does this mean for the future? If demand continues to rise, housing prices will continue rising or at least stabilize. The first factor -- distressed sales --- will become less of a factor in the future as we approach normalized levels of distressed sales.

The key is demand. If the economy continues to produce jobs at a decent rate, then we will have a greater demand for the real estate market. That is what makes November's employment report interesting. Heading into December we had a series of numbers which pointed to a stronger jobs market, including the lowest number of first time claims for unemployment benefits since before the recession started and a strong October employment report. This made the markets optimistic before the numbers were released. And the numbers did not disappoint as the economy once again created more than 200,000 jobs and the unemployment rate dropped to 7.0%.

Mike Ervin

Mortgage Banker

NMLS # 252715

C: 650.766.8500

mike@mikeervin.com

The Muddled Oil Picture

We find it kind of interesting that the stock market continues to hit records at a time in which oil prices are moderating. Conventional wisdom tells us that the stock market rallies when the economy is getting stronger. A stronger economy causes higher demand for energy. That would cause oil and gas prices to rise. Yet, in August oil prices pushed to approximately $110 per barrel and by the middle of November, they had receded to below $95.00 per barrel. In the meantime, in the middle of November stock prices hit record levels again. Why the disconnect? Some of the drop in oil prices could be associated with the uncertainty which accompanied the government shutdown -- however the stock market did not seem to be affected by the shutdown and oil prices did not rebound when the shutdown was over. There are also seasonal factors. We got through the hurricane season without any major storms which could have damaged our ability to produce oil. Finally, the progress towards the Iranian nuclear agreement also weighed in on oil prices.

On the other hand, there were some additional important announcements that are affecting the overall picture. The International Energy Agency reported that the U.S. will surpass Saudi Arabia as the top oil producer in the world by 2015. The Administration also announced in November that our oil production is at a 24-year high and our imports are at a 17-year low. The factors for this include both new oil extraction technologies such as fracking and more energy efficient cars. Long-term projections in the IEA report were not as optimistic; however, for now the energy picture is getting better. Why is this important? As the economy grows, if oil prices also increase this causes a drag on economic growth. If in 2014 oil prices stay where they are, consumers will have more money to spend in other areas --from furniture to cars to houses. In other words, if it holds the oil price picture could be very good news. Meanwhile this week we will see another jobs report. This one is sure to be interesting as a follow-up to the surprisingly strong report from the previous month.

 

Mike Ervin

NMLS # 252715

C: 650.766.8500

P: 650.735.5261

mike@mikeervin.com